The solved case of Shannon Melendi.
Shannon Denise Melendi was born on October 20, 1974 in Miami, Florida to parents Yvonne & Luis Melendi. Friends & family described her as being social, outgoing, hardworking, goal-oriented, and athletic. She had plans & dreams of serving in the Navy and going to law school to have a career in politics, hoping to be on the Supreme Court someday. After graduating from Southwest High School in 1992, she received a scholarship to attend Emory University in Atlanta, Georgia to study political science & Spanish.
During her freshman year of college, she was hired by the Carter Center in Atlanta and also worked part time as a scorekeeper at a softball field in Decatur, Georgia. She continued working both jobs in her sophomore year.
March 26, 1994, should’ve been a typical Saturday for 19 year old Shannon. She attended the softball game and kept score throughout the morning until 12:40 that afternoon. When her shift was over, she went to the Citgo gas station across the street for her lunch break. After that, she was never seen or heard from again.
Her roommates were immediately suspicious and reported Shannon missing when she didn’t show up the next day, they also went out to search for her. Her car was found at a local gas station with the keys still in the ignition, but Shannon wasn’t there and there was no sign of her. Shannon’s parents came to Atlanta after learning that their daughter was missing, they helped in the search and put flyers around the area. Unfortunately, authorities didn’t do much at the time and said Shannon had run away and would probably return in a few days.
Shannon’s whereabouts were unknown, but there was a suspect in her disappearance. It was the umpire during the softball game on the day she disappeared who had a criminal record, Colvin “Butch” Hinton. He had served time in jail for raping a 14 year old girl in 1982 and had reportedly been staring at Shannon during when he should’ve been paying attention to the softball game and went to lunch with her. On April 6, 1994, the counseling center at Emory University received a call from an anonymous man claiming he had Shannon and that she was safe. The call was traced to a pay phone where a small bag was found that contained Shannon’s blue topaz ring.
Six months after Shannon’s disappearance, Hinton’s house caught on fire which was determined to be arson for insurance money. On January 27, 1995, in Jonesboro, Georgia, he attacked a young woman who worked at the same McDonalds as him. He was convicted in 1995 for arson and insurance fraud and spent seven years in federal prison, a neighbor said another fire had been set the day Shannon disappeared. Investigators searched his house and found possible evidence of other crimes, there was lots of women’s clothing that didn’t belong to his wife or Shannon Melendi although he did confess to her murder while in prison, which caused detectives to open the case again.
Microscopic evidence confirmed Hinton had left the ring there, the masking tape matched tape found in his garage. Butch Hinton was finally arrested for Shannon Melendi’s murder on August 30, 2004. The trial began on August 22, 2005 and ended on September 19, 2005. He was sentenced to life in prison with possibility of parole, it was the first conviction in Georgia without a body.
On July 17, 2006, he confessed exactly what he did to Shannon the day she disappeared. He said after inviting her out to lunch, he intentionally took a wrong turn before faking a leg cramp and asking Shannon to drive. Once in the passenger seat, he pulled out a knife and ordered her to drive to his house in Rex, Georgia. When they arrived, he handcuffed Shannon to his bed and made some calls to establish an alibi. He continued to rape her, telling her that he only wanted to steal her car. After coming home from the movies with his niece & nephew, he grabbed one of his ties and strangled her and burned her body in the garage. To this day, Shannon’s body has never been found and she is still considered a missing person.
Hinton was eligible for parole in 2012 & 2020, but both appeals were denied. Shannon’s mother Denise passed away from pneumonia on May 19, 2021 but her father & younger sister Monique continue to fight to keep him behind bars whenever he’s eligible for parole. The family raised awareness for the case earlier this year for the 30th anniversary of Shannon’s disappearance and murder to sign a petition that would keep Hinton in jail without possibility of parole, and the search for Shannon’s remains continues today. Had Shannon Melendi lived, she’d be 50.
Thank you for reading, have a wonderful day and happy new year!. Continue reading
Comments
Post a Comment